NHacker Next
  • new
  • past
  • show
  • ask
  • show
  • jobs
  • submit
▲Backblaze customers worried of personal data sale/sharing after policy update (neowin.net)
mzajc 2 hours ago [-]
A few in-place encryption solutions for cloud storage:

- Rclone crypt: https://rclone.org/crypt/

- Cryptomator: https://cryptomator.org/

- (for incremental backups) Restic: https://restic.net/

This should be a hard requirement for anyone storing data on someone else's computer. Barring vulnerabilities, you can essentially disregard the service's privacy policy, and select purely based on price and reliability.

chris_st 42 minutes ago [-]
Also Arq (for Mac and windows) - https://www.arqbackup.com/
moonlighter 4 minutes ago [-]
Been an Arq user for years (Mac only), backing up to Amazon S3. The yearly price is reasonable (1-time purchase with 12 months of updates for $60 per computer) I set a budget for $10 on S3 and it keeps plenty of incremental backups for my 1TB Mac mini. It's mostly set-it-and-forget-it.
mijoharas 2 hours ago [-]
Very happy restic user here, I'd strongly recommend it to everyone.
jonny2811 46 minutes ago [-]
love restic.

I used veracrypt for a long time, but the encrypted vault is just one gigantic blob, which makes incremental backups hard, i recently switched to https://github.com/rfjakob/gocryptfs which encrypts the files and the filenames, as a results it's way easier to sync with any tool, even something like Dropbox.

AmazingEveryDay 1 hours ago [-]
> you can essentially disregard the service's privacy policy

At some point the obvious step for these services is to disallow storage of encrypted data, yes?

3eb7988a1663 47 minutes ago [-]
I assume data storage companies already hate encryption. Without encryption, you probably get a lot of redundant blocks that do not have to be materialized to disk. That is, if a bunch of your customers have, ahem, acquired the same copy of Dune, you only need to store it once. With encryption, all data looks random, so there is no way to further compress it.
Routine8502 18 minutes ago [-]
I mean, they charge per TB, right? Why does it bother them if the data is compressible or not? Or are you saying that if, hypothetically, 100 customers have a copy of the same 100 GB Dune ripped identically from DVDs they legally own, that the storage companies would store 100, but charge for 1000? Boo-fucking-hoo, then.
3eb7988a1663 6 minutes ago [-]
It all weighs into their business model for costs.

If you upload an uncompressed 10MB markdown file to Amazon S3, Amazon will charge you for 10MB of storage, but is almost certainly going to use some internal compression so that they only have to commit 500KB to disk. Given enough scale, and you can project that every x TB of customer data only actually requires y TB of storage space. If all ingested data is already encrypted, x now equals y and that savings ratio disappears, so you are going to have to provision x storage hardware.

foobarchu 3 minutes ago [-]
If they can compress, they get to charge you the same amount while saving their own cost, increasing margins.
rsync 41 minutes ago [-]
"This should be a hard requirement for anyone storing data on someone else's computer."

Agreed.

With regard to rclone, remember that there is a very interesting and useful workflow which combines rclone and restic to produce append-only backups at the destination of your choice:

https://www.rsync.net/resources/notes/2025-q4-rsync.net_tech...

  rclone serve restic --stdio ...
... is the form of this workflow and the howto linked above is NOT rsync.net specific - it can be used anywhere.
inovica 2 hours ago [-]
Thanks for the links. They look useful. Not sure about Cryptomator, but the others look good
8by3 1 hours ago [-]
Hard agree.

Been using rclone on B2 for ever, only ever push encrypted files there, with encrypted filenames so good luck using them for marketing or whatever.

cube00 4 hours ago [-]
Related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50585593

I reposted because after the rename of the thread above, the problematic nature of these changes are lost using the generic privacy policy page title.

Backblaze Notice at Collection and Privacy Policy: https://www.backblaze.com/company/policy/privacy

The table feels confusing with the spanned center cell but if I'm reading it correctly, all of the following fall under "Sold or Shared for Targeted Advertising: Yes"

* Identifiers: For example, a name, address, Internet Protocol address, email address, or other similar identifiers.

* Commercial Information: For example, records of personal property, products or services purchased, obtained, or considered, or other purchasing or consuming histories or tendencies.

* Internet or Other Similar Network Activity: For example, browsing history, search history, and information regarding a consumer’s interaction with an Internet Web site, application, or advertisement.

* Geolocation Data: For example, information that can be used to determine a device’s physical location.

Opt out at https://preferences.backblaze.com

mijoharas 2 hours ago [-]
Why are people posting about encryption? First off, you should be encrypting your backups anyways, secondly they explicitly say that backup content is excluded from all of this.

Can anyone say whether it's third party sharing (i.e. using Google analytics) or selling of personal data? (The article says "sale or sharing")

Because I've got little problem with the former, and a big problem with the latter.

I'm particularly interested because I had a TODO item of my own for setting up backblaze as an alternate restic backend, but now I'd probably like a little more clarity before going ahead.

3eb7988a1663 38 minutes ago [-]
Like the recent brouhaha about Proton email, this business decision breaks user trust. Email and backups are the most personal digital information available. For a business to do anything to violate the integrity of that agreement forever taints every action. Today it is only "metadata" - how long until they again alter the deal?

People previously felt like they could trust the Backblaze client to faithfully mirror their data. No longer. That client may decide that it has the right to inspect some "harmless" metadata that would be valuable to advertisers. Will the software start scanning browser cookies of recently visited sites? Pull GPS coordinates of recently acquired photos?

From this moment, running Backblaze software is an unacceptable risk, and the convenience of the service is now negligible. Privacy focused individuals will have to setup their own encryption pipeline using trusted software to dump encrypted blocks onto Backblaze servers.

cube00 2 hours ago [-]
> Can anyone say whether it's third party sharing (i.e. using Google analytics) or selling of personal data?

What We Sell to Third Parties or Share with Third Parties for Cross-Context Behavioral Advertising and Right to Opt-Out

We have sold or shared with third parties for cross-context behavioral advertising (e.g., targeted advertising) the following categories of personal information to advertising networks and analytics providers in the preceding 12 months: Identifiers; Internet or Other Similar Network Activity; Commercial Information; Geolocation Data. We do not sell or share sensitive personal information.

Don't be fooled by "identifiers" either: Identifiers: For example, a name, address, Internet Protocol address, email address, or other similar identifiers.

https://www.backblaze.com/company/policy/privacy

mijoharas 1 hours ago [-]
I don't feel that this really answers my question.

I feel that utilising a few quite normal advertising third parties would match that description, and so would selling data to some shady data brokers. Can anyone infer which it is?

krisroadruck 3 hours ago [-]
People are freaking out for no reason. This is a reaction to some legal shenanigans run wild in California - people getting sued for CIPA "wiretapping" for having things like Hotjar session replay, and overly zealous interpretation of "selling data" for things like having google analytics and ads tracking pixels installed for re-marketing to your own website visitors. Lots of places are being forced to update their privacy policies to avoid being sued into the dirt over basic tracking on their websites. The tell is the privacy choices thing. This is very likely entirely related to Google Analytics/Ads (esp re-targeting) + Tag Manager.
dawnerd 2 hours ago [-]
If that was a case they could come out and just say so. But it’s been radio silence from them.
krisroadruck 2 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
cube00 2 hours ago [-]
The way they've tried to minimise this in the email notification and provided no diff between the two versions doesn't fill me with confidence.

  Privacy Notice 
   Updated to improve clarity and organization, and to reflect current legal requirements.
krisroadruck 2 hours ago [-]
They literally link to the old version from the new version: backblaze.com/company/policy/privacy-april-2026

Normal communication to normal people doesn't involve sending diffs. I feel like I'm practically shilling for these guys just by having to point out obvious stuff.

Just to be clear - no affiliation with backblaze, not even a customer. Just have to deal with privacy policy updates all the time for customers. Poke around in google or run these comments through an LLM of choice. This is really pretty benign stuff lots of companies are being forced to do because of legal trolls running wild in California over the last year or so.

voakbasda 2 hours ago [-]
So the solution is to get their customers to pay more rather than to stop doing the thing that will get them sued?

No, there is profit motive in this.

krisroadruck 2 hours ago [-]
The profit motive is the ability to continue to run re-marketing ads targeting people who visited their site but haven't yet purchased. The cost in the current legal environment is to make minor adjustments to their privacy policy, because not doing so opens them up to a lawsuit. I thought I was pretty clear on this, no conspiracy required.
voakbasda 2 hours ago [-]
The cost to consumers is the slippery slope that is leading directly to the complete loss of privacy.
pessimizer 1 hours ago [-]
> minor adjustments

Begging the question.

> not doing so opens them up to a lawsuit.

Evidence that these adjustments are not minor.

krisroadruck 1 hours ago [-]
* minor wording adjustments

* Having legally compliant policy safeguards against lawsuits from legal trolls who focus on low hanging fruit. The wording requirement to meet that standard changes from time to time, necessitating minor adjustments to stay compliant.

I miss when hacker news was filled with intellectually curious people instead of quasi-clever types. This place has become exhausting.

You guys win. Normal privacy policy adjustments are all actually EvilCo secret plans to sell your cat photos to the highest bidder for AI. Couldn't possibly be anything else. Certainly it's not the sort of thing you could put literally 3 minutes of research into instead of just arguing from a starting position of "must be malice".

dabinat 3 hours ago [-]
I’m currently an unhappy customer of Backblaze B2, working to switch to another company. Their service has serious performance problems at night, which their engineers were able to reproduce, but they don’t consider important enough to fix. My experience dealing with their support team was suggestive of serious systemic problems with company management and culture.

It does not surprise me that they would do this as their priority seems to be cashing in on AI and not delivering a decent service to customers.

k0morebi 1 hours ago [-]
What serious performance issues? What are examples of the "serious systemic problems with management and culture". I like to draw my own conclusions based on the facts. Without details, it just reads like a reddit hit post

I've had zero issues, ever. But I'm not a heavy user. Just backups to b2 via restic. Never any issues with uploads or downloads or service availability.

radlad 2 hours ago [-]
Similar experience with their client libraries: they appear poorly maintained and it causes downstream issues when their API changes.

I'm looking at S3 or Bunny - I need something I don't self-host, as I use it for Terraform (OpenTofu) state, among other things.

mistic92 2 hours ago [-]
I have similar experience but I don't know where can I migrate. I'm syncing my backups from qnap there.
sigmonsays 3 hours ago [-]
use restic and they can't get any info from your files. However, on principal i might start looking elsewhere. I have almost a couple TB I think with them.
thatonehack 3 hours ago [-]
Always encrypt your data prior to sending to any cloud service. Extra points for obscuring file names as part of an automatic process.
xvxvx 4 hours ago [-]
I have a suspicion that they’re wanting to move away from consumer backups to using the storage for AI and cashing in. This seems like a good way to encourage customers to leave and free up storage. Price hikes will take care of the rest.
wilkystyle 3 hours ago [-]
I also suspect that it may be related to AI, but not in the way you are thinking. Storage is cheap and data is incredibly valuable. There's a lot of money to be had in collecting user data for AI to train on.
amelius 3 hours ago [-]
Yes and what company cares about laws anymore these days?
Ungh 3 hours ago [-]
I've learned in the last few years that you should never give anyone your data even if they have the best terms in place. When revenue is short or opportunity is high, principles and terms are changed. And then it's too late.
import 2 hours ago [-]
Use age + rclone if anyone not doing encryption
mijoharas 2 hours ago [-]
No, use restic[0]. (Note: age and rclone are both nice tools. Restic is better for this)

[0] https://words.filippo.io/right-answers/

odo1242 54 minutes ago [-]
Rclone is if you’re using the storage as storage and frequently creating/deleting stuff. Restic is for backups.
ostensible 3 hours ago [-]
This is a high grade bs. The bottom of journalism. "Customers are worried". Who is specifically worried? Where are sources?

Post the problematic parts of updated terms if you want a discussion. Don't turn this into yellow press tabloid.

3eb7988a1663 19 minutes ago [-]
Did you read the linked Reddit thread? Or see the comments in the previous HN post? Would it make you feel better if they said Reddituser-abc said, "I am worried"?

I doubt you are going to see a commentary from Bruce Schneier or the EFF about the security implications of this. Which leaves randos on the internet, whose name is meaningless to the rest of the audience.

The policy changed, as a rando user of the internet, I think it is a terribly worrying policy decision.

ChrisArchitect 2 hours ago [-]
theturtle 19 minutes ago [-]
[dead]
Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact
Rendered at 19:37:58 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.