NHacker Next
  • new
  • past
  • show
  • ask
  • show
  • jobs
  • submit
▲'Birdbrain' Is a Misnomer. Crows Make Decisions Faster Than We Can (nytimes.com)
Animats 1 hours ago [-]
Intelligence has evolved on Earth at least three times - mammals, corvids, and octopuses. All the mammals have roughly the same brain architecture. But the corvids are not on the same evolutionary branch, and have a different neuron design and a different brain architecture. "Such behavioral flexibility might seem unexpected because a layered cerebral cortex, the highest integration center in the mammalian brain, is not existant in birds."[1] So there's more than one way to do intelligence. Useful to know for AI purposes.

Octopuses have a much more distributed system than mammals, suggesting a quite different approach is possible.

[1] https://niederlab.org/Nieder%20(2017)%20COBS.pdf

greymalik 10 minutes ago [-]
Adrian Tchaikovsky explores each of these kinds of intelligence across his sci-fi Children of Time trilogy.
0xBA5ED 2 hours ago [-]
The title doesn't make sense because "bridbrain" doesn't imply slow decision making.
echelon 1 hours ago [-]
As a native speaker, "birdbrain" means stupid.

The term implies something that feels like "dodo" or imbecile.

Corvids and parrots and raptors are remarkably smart, yet not every bird species is. Some are incredibly stupid.

There's also the anecdote (maybe just in the American South?) of a chicken running around with its head cut off.

Also think of the "Always Sunny" meme where they call Dee a "bird" all the time [1]. It's meant to mean stupid, amongst other things.

[1] https://youtu.be/60D7SN06A8M

dieselgate 3 minutes ago [-]
Some sayings are wrong or half-truth but they stick anyway e.g. "blind as a bat".
GauntletWizard 49 minutes ago [-]
Mike the headless chicken was extensively documented, if an incredible fluke. He also had an intact brainstem, even if not a full brain. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_the_Headless_Chicken
skupig 14 minutes ago [-]
Sure, and you can reach a stupid decision quickly. "Birdbrain" has never had a connotation of being slow to react.
deadnomore 23 minutes ago [-]
Yeah I can think of plenty of impulsive and dumb things to do without much thought.
tapland 2 hours ago [-]
Yeah it implies.. what I see when I look at some of the !@#$ my pigeons and budgies do.
davrosthedalek 1 hours ago [-]
Do they do that slowly or quickly?
toast0 32 minutes ago [-]
My chickens do what passes for thinking quickly. Not that it passes well.
dlcarrier 1 hours ago [-]
Those birds are geniuses, compared to chickens.
WalterBright 15 minutes ago [-]
They might think faster because the brain is smaller - a shorter distance for connections.

For example, learning to play a piano is training the spine, not the brain. Because the feedback loop with the spine is shorter.

It's the same with dancing. One is trained to not look at one's feet, because the feedback loop is too slow.

randomImmigrant 59 minutes ago [-]
Birdbrain should mean the opposite of what it does, for this reason, but for many others. Birds can sense the Earth's magnetic field and use it for navigation, a process that's about the one bona fide quantum biological paradigm.

Their body clocks are also significantly more sophisticated and decentralized than ours.

And in the end, the physical intelligence of flight itself demands a brain that's gotta be incredibly spatially and temporally aware.

I wish our brains had some of the skills and efficiencies of birds.

gumby 41 minutes ago [-]
> Birds can sense the Earth's magnetic field and use it for navigation, a process that's about the one bona fide quantum biological paradigm… I wish our brains had some of the skills and efficiencies of birds.

You can harness your somatic infrastructure to gain some senses, like magnetic field sensitivity. Some people implant small permanent magnets in a fingertip to sense magnetic field, and claim it makes the world more interesting.

Unfortunately such an implant is not itself permanent (you'd want to coat it with something safe that doesn't trigger the immune system like gold or PTFE). Also though you want to be careful around other magnets I imagine!

But you could probably wear a magnetic sensor that used something attached to your skin that you could learn to "read" intuitively. The problems are dermatalogical sensitivity from the adhesive and the inability to wear it 24/7 to make the erading really feel like a new sense. But who knows?

whatever1 2 hours ago [-]
They have to be faster than us. They casually fly at 40mph.
RachelF 34 minutes ago [-]
From an engineering point of view their control loop must be much faster. Things that fly need much tighter loops than we do that lumber about on the ground.

Watch a bird come in fast and then land on a narrow twig.

Bird neurons are roughly half the length of mammal neurons. This means you can pack in around 8x more neurons in a given volume.

inglor_cz 1 hours ago [-]
Some of the traditional folk tale stereotypes seem to be correlated quite well to what we now know about bird cognition.

Hens/chickens are usually synonymous with "not very bright". Crows and ravens are usually depicted as smart and cunning.

alpineman 1 hours ago [-]
Chickens actually have a very advanced social intelligence though
AnthonBerg 36 minutes ago [-]
Ah!, thanks! [lightbulb]

Went to find something to read on the matter. This paper is fun!: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10071-016-1064-4

bitwize 2 hours ago [-]
I know more than one person who believe that certain birds, especially crows, ravens, and cardinals, are reincarnated loved ones bringing a message.

I don't share this belief, but the more we find out about avian intelligence, the less surprised we should be that people actually think this.

SoftTalker 2 hours ago [-]
Given the tiny size of avian brains compare to mammals, particulary humans, it's hard to ascribe a lot of intelligence to them. But for what they can do, they seem quite well optimized.
fsiefken 1 hours ago [-]
Brain size is not a decisive factor in estimating intelligence and corvid brains pack twice the neurons per volume compared to humans. The factor is: effective "Information Processing Capacity" (IPC), which is high for body size and rivals great apes on specific executive tasks.

Extreme miniaturization eliminates travel distance, giving near-zero latency and high metabolic efficiency despite 1/5th the neurons of a chimp.

leftbit 1 hours ago [-]
Bird brains are wired differently, neuron density is higher... so using size to compare brains is not enough.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/bird-brains-have-...

misnome 2 hours ago [-]
And that’s why Elephants are generally considered more intelligent than humans!
dools 7 minutes ago [-]
Jev brained
amelius 1 hours ago [-]
It's faster probably because their neural network is less deep :)
dlcarrier 1 hours ago [-]
Humans think fast and slow, but birds only think fast.
newobj 1 hours ago [-]
"eat like a bird" is also a misnomer. birds are so misunderstood
functionmouse 1 hours ago [-]
Yeah, well... My SHARP pocket calculator turns on faster than my PC does.
EmX_3000 49 minutes ago [-]
I hate popular science articles like this. Ummmmm listen sweetie, you're just ignorant and Ima police you a bit here... sit down for some really wild SCIENCEism!

Ugh.

39 minutes ago [-]
Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact
Rendered at 20:25:33 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.