NHacker Next
  • new
  • past
  • show
  • ask
  • show
  • jobs
  • submit
▲FAA Issues National Ground Stop (fly.faa.gov)
nxobject 21 minutes ago [-]
Secretary Mullin/DHS is confirming that this will likely be an extended outage...

> “This isn’t going to just be be resolved and turned around within the hour"

https://www.nytimes.com/live/2026/11/13/us/ground-stop-natio...

throwaway27448 3 minutes ago [-]
[delayed]
Animats 14 minutes ago [-]
Info on this is amazingly sparse. Apparently Sec. Duffy posted something on X/Twitter, and that's all the news media have.

Looking at LAX departures, it looks like nothing has departed since about 10:30 AM PST, and everything later is showing Delayed or Cancelled. There are times after Delayed, but it's not clear those times mean anything. Some are now in the past.

"flysfo.com" is too overloaded to display departures. Stuck at "loading...".

JFK departure status shows almost solid "Delayed".

No good explanations anywhere.

Maxion 6 minutes ago [-]
Surprised there's not been any updates yet. Not even one of this will continue or it is being resolved.
awefkjawelfkja0 3 minutes ago [-]
Sec of Homeland Security gave an interview about 10 minutes ago saying it's indefinite, they don't know the cause, and to expect resolution to take a while.
mikewarot 22 minutes ago [-]
I'm watching it live on ADSBexhange, here's a flight I picked at random going approximately past me that'll land in Detroit about an hour from now... there's not much left over the US over 40,000 feet. Only 2 planes over Indiana at that altitude right now.

https://globe.adsbexchange.com/?icao=a519b8

It's Delta Airlines flight 1070

https://www.flightaware.com/live/flight/DAL1070

EvanAnderson 19 minutes ago [-]
I'm watching ADSBexchange too.

It's eerie seeing the total number of aircraft tracked decrease. I put on a filter for 1000' to 80000', to exclude aircraft on the ground, and the number was around 12K when I started watching. It's down to just over 9.4K now. Wild.

aschla 15 minutes ago [-]
To be fair, above FL400 4̶0̶A̶G̶L̶ is relatively high for most airliners. Most are between FL300 and FL400.
rogerrogerr 11 minutes ago [-]
FL400. 40 AGL is doable for almost all airliners ;)
aschla 7 minutes ago [-]
Thanks. Meant to slap a k on that 40.
erickhill 7 minutes ago [-]
Absolutely tons between 10K-20k, though.
throwitaway222 1 hours ago [-]
Anyone have a screen shot? I just see "NO Advisory"

edit: https://www.fly.faa.gov/ois/oisedit/adv_oisedit_dis?number=1...

lxgr 1 hours ago [-]

    ATCSCC Advisory
    ATCSCC 111 DCC 11/13/2026 NATIONAL GROUND STOP 

    EVENT TIME: 13/2053 - 14/0400
    DUE TO EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES AND FOR REASONS OF SAFETY.
    ATTENTION ALL AIRCRAFT OPERATORS, BY ORDER OF THE FEDERAL AVIATION
    COMMAND CENTER ALL AIRPORTS ARE GROUND STOPPED. ALL DEPARTING
    TRAFFIC SHOULD REMAIN GROUND STOPPED UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE. INBOUND
    INTERNATIONAL FLIGHTS WILL BE MANAGED ON A CASE BY CASE BASIS.
franze 20 minutes ago [-]
Why

13/2053

?

agildehaus 5 minutes ago [-]
It's a format called "Date-Time Group" (DTG). Used in military, I think it dates back to teletypes, and is better to say over radio than modern ISO formats.

You'd say "Valid from the thirteenth at two zero five three zulu" over radio.

dcrazy 17 minutes ago [-]
My guess at parsing: in effect from 8:53pm UTC on the 13th to 4am UTC on the 14th.
goldfingeroo7 2 minutes ago [-]
Friday the 13th at 08:53 PM UTC
Maxion 19 minutes ago [-]
UTC
0cf8612b2e1e 10 minutes ago [-]
Airplane software is some of the oldest on the planet, pre-dating anything that would be considered a best practice. When you see something weird in the space, assume it is because someone in the 1960s thought using more than two characters world be a profligate waste of space.

Unrolling these decisions is a monumental task given the decades of hardware already deployed in the field that will only be upgraded when the current unit fails.

tniemi 34 minutes ago [-]
Holy french.
mikeyouse 1 hours ago [-]
kulahan 57 minutes ago [-]
For anyone who doesn’t want to click through, there are problems with “frequencies”. Something must be jamming up the airways… but nationwide??
inamberclad 55 minutes ago [-]
Probably a telecom issue. Most radio transmitters are operated over phone or Internet from a remote station.
chinathrow 27 minutes ago [-]
Teams phone down?
sippingabonedry 5 minutes ago [-]
Are these systems dependent on landlines?

VZW and AT&T are moving full tilt in shutting down landline central offices.

Literally the gay dude from Airplane pulling the plug from the socket may have happened here.

bbor 43 minutes ago [-]
Oh nice, very helpful. The sibling thread mentions that this problem is specific to "ARTCCs", which are not the towers at airports but rather central hubs:

  Between the sectors administered by [smaller towers] are 20 contiguous areas of US airspace above 18,000 feet, each managed by an Air Route Traffic Control Center (ARTCC)...
  A flight is handed off from one Center to another until it descends near its destination, when control is transferred to the TRACON serving the destination, and ultimately to the tower controller serving the airport.
Wikipedia mentions they in particular use special "very high frequency aviation bands" (around "AM 118-137 MHz"), which is presumably why they're all linked together. It also mentions sharing systems, but no clear specifics that I can find. Certainly doesn't disprove the botched rollout theory, tho...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Area_control_center

EDIT: someone below posted this, seems relevant -- the 'Radar multiplexer pipeline' that's on a "fast track" and an "aggressive track": https://www.sunhillo.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/SUN3125-... TL;DR: upgrading radio systems from old analog tech to new digital tech, I think?

londons_explore 28 minutes ago [-]
I'd be shocked if someone greenlighted an atc upgrade procedure which involves closing all US airspace to do the switchover.
lxgr 9 minutes ago [-]
That’s obviously not what’s happening. But if this upgrade is really implicated, the real question would be where the line of accepted residual risk for an outage like this was drawn.
cobychapple 35 minutes ago [-]
java-man 40 minutes ago [-]
ryanschaefer 54 minutes ago [-]
Seems “not great” that the notice isn’t even showing…
brendoelfrendo 1 hours ago [-]
It disappeared briefly, but is back now.
lxgr 57 minutes ago [-]
Same here, I get it only on some refreshes, otherwise it shows "no advisories". I hope that's not the main path these things are disseminated normally.
adamsb6 43 minutes ago [-]
This thing is probably getting 10,000+% normal traffic, database is timing out on some queries, and it represents no answer as no notice.
lxgr 36 minutes ago [-]
That would be a pretty concerning way of handling database failures, but I suspect you might be right.
amluto 41 minutes ago [-]
I have no idea whether this particular failure was Microsoft's fault, but I was in the air on September 14, 2004 when a substantial portion of the southwestern US's air traffic control went down:

https://spectrum.ieee.org/lost-radio-contact-leaves-pilots-o...

(I was near ORD at the time, flying toward the outage area. We diverted to ORD, and the pilot was very friendly about it.)

At the time I thought it was Microsoft's fault, as Windows 95 and 98 were susceptible to crashing when GetTickCount() overflowed, and this ATC crash was due to a 32-bit millisecond counter on a Windows machine overflowing, but in this particular instance the system was apparently not running on a version of Windows with this particular bug and the failure was just an application error.

Aren't computers great? :)

Waterluvian 36 minutes ago [-]
By chance were you flying an F-22 Raptor?
jtwaleson 5 minutes ago [-]
This sounds like the beginning of a good story.
add-sub-mul-div 31 minutes ago [-]
People need to stop letting their thinking be dominated by the previous day's headlines.
Vegenoid 28 minutes ago [-]
Hypothesizing that today’s big tech outage may be related to the big tech outage that was less than 24 hours ago is natural and sensible.
LdBaringSwallow 20 minutes ago [-]
For anyone tasked with resolving those problems.

For anyone else it's unproductive rubber necking

LPisGood 17 minutes ago [-]
If I’m not tasked with solving the problems then is there anything I can do for that is productive? Discussing it at all seems like unproductive rubbernecking.
JsonDemWitOster 15 minutes ago [-]
Sir, this is an internet forum. Why are you here if you have problems to resolve?
devmor 12 minutes ago [-]
Why is anyone else expected to be productive in their speculation?
LdBaringSwallow 4 minutes ago [-]
Because for every minute you don't spend on yourself means someone else has to pick up the slack; you are not an island.

Thermodynamics is like that.

And the rest of us would rather deal with our own lives than your preference to sit about reflecting; none of us have a contract with you specifically so pitter patter, you're not our problem

That's why I am all about robots doing the work; at least up to filling stores with textiles, food, building materials, and leaving everyone's "day job" to staying out the way of others who just want to experience consciousness and die.

Have worked among the people for 30ish years; started on farms, got degrees in EE/CE, worked in hardware/software; we are going in circles so drop the rhetorical pretense.

It's western vanity fueled by old allegory of religion about forever life and prosperity; my decades of experience studying applied physics and watching software engineers circumlocutions but now using fancy new JS lib! are little more than a scratched record jumping backwards to the previous groove

LdBaringSwallow 21 minutes ago [-]
Agreed. I would apply this further; stop letting 1970s and 1980s pop culture fads consume our attention; let go of Star Wars and Marvel etc etc; previous centuries headlines

Let go of software dev; as is a mechanical task from the 60s-70s

Cultural memory begets cultural conservatism

mdemare 7 minutes ago [-]
But we can still keep Monty Python, right?
17 minutes ago [-]
verandaguy 17 minutes ago [-]
God forbid the news cycle slow down enough for society to process events rather than being continuously forcefed the next thing in the outrage cycle.

This is why there's such an issue with holding power to account nowadays.

Vegenoid 5 minutes ago [-]
I think you’ve misunderstood- this is an outage, not an outrage
freediddy 29 minutes ago [-]
To err is human.

To really fuck up, you need a computer.

randysalami 7 seconds ago [-]
I wrote about this four days ago:

"Realistically you want fewer, higher-quality engineers who are educated in these tools and treat them with respect and caution. These tools are dangerous and you can’t play around. All it takes is one mistake and the blast radius is way, way larger. One mistake can do so much damage it undos all value of an entire year. Before downloading a malicious dependency was limited to deterministic behavior and could be scanned for. Now, you run a MCP server locally, it can prompt inject (in many different ways), and now your super powerful AI buddy is hacking you in ways a deterministic piece of malware could never. You could cripple entire companies through negligent use." And "And now we are controlling models that can be hacked in so many different ways and literally blow up companies. It used to be accountability the software wouldn’t break. Now it’s accountability that in creating the software we don’t ruin the business."

Not saying this was caused by malicious actors or negligent AI agent usage nor am I saying was the previous Microsoft outage either the above references but it doesn't look great. If our technology is really so brittle, we might be looking at a return to way slower world to put it simply. Maybe no remote work because it gets hacked too easy!

EvanAnderson 25 minutes ago [-]
Computers are machines used to amplify human error.
NateEag 19 minutes ago [-]
> A computer is a device that enables a person to make more mistakes faster than any previous invention, with the possible exception of the combination of handguns and tequila.

-- some clever person whose name I do not know

35 minutes ago [-]
armcat 49 minutes ago [-]
More info on AP [1]. Looks like a comms issue. The figures they quoted for the overhaul are absolutely insane - almost $45 billion (I used to work in telecom):

> "The government has been working to overhaul the outdated technology that air traffic controllers rely on since Congress approved $12.5 billion for the project last year."

> "Duffy has said that another $30 billion will be needed to complete the work, and the White House has begun lobbying Congress to approve it."

[1] https://apnews.com/article/flights-halted-airports-faa-f81b0...

greggsy 22 minutes ago [-]
What is the cost of grounding all flights across the USA for one day?
LPisGood 13 minutes ago [-]
I’ve seen figures that estimate the aviation industry to provide about $1.5 trillion worth of GDP for America, so 4-5 billion dollars. Feel free to double that for the cost of dealing with unexpected disruptions and loss of institutional trust.
davedx 16 minutes ago [-]
It's because air traffic control systems in the US haven't been significantly upgraded in like a century. Keep kicking the can it will get more and more expensive
chasd00 33 minutes ago [-]
Never let a crisis goto waste. Someone screws up and the first reaction is to say “we need more money”
ethbr1 8 minutes ago [-]
> first reaction

The FAA et al. have been working to modernize US ATC since ~2003. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Next_Generation_Air_Transporta...

The next step is a ton of hardware upgrading, which always costs real money.

AnimalMuppet 10 minutes ago [-]
When the system is held together with chewing gum and 1980s-era software, when it fails, "someone screws up" is not a fair reaction. Of course it fails! The wonder is that it still mostly works.
sailfast 20 minutes ago [-]
They asked for the money before the crisis which makes the timing even MORE conspiracy coded somehow
kulahan 15 minutes ago [-]
Should probably have waited 48 hours for the news cycle to move on and ensure absolutely nobody knows the money is needed
vulture916 20 minutes ago [-]
Hold on, let me fire up Claude…
m_kos 2 minutes ago [-]
I set up a basic tracker here. AI is updating it hourly, so always verify yourself.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vThhccsTanAz...

sixhobbits 5 minutes ago [-]
Botched rollout of AI for ATC announced yesterday as rolling out nationwide?

> The agency wrote on Nov. 10 that after the D.C. test, it will “now use SMART in the airspace of all 22 centers across the country to reduce delays, reduce fuel consumption and improve the travel experience for the flying public.” The tech was already being deployed at some airports.

https://gizmodo.com/the-faa-is-rolling-out-its-ai-air-traffi...

jbredeche 1 hours ago [-]
On a plane about to take off and obviously we didn’t. The captain is very confused and says he doesn’t know what this means.
kevvok 53 minutes ago [-]
Same at SJC. The captain basically said, “IDK what to do, so I’m just going to read the bulletin Alaska sent out”
kevvok 9 minutes ago [-]
Now we’ve been deplaned and they are going to return checked baggage to us
ethbr1 5 minutes ago [-]
Hate that for all involved. Was flying out of ATL when the Crowdstrike clusterfuck imploded Delta's antiquated crew scheduling backends. Not a fun night.

Godspeed for everyone getting to where they need to be, somehow, or at least ending tonight with a roof over your heads.

condour75 5 minutes ago [-]
We were offered $1500 to get on a later flight and I’m so glad I didn’t get to the counter on time to take them up on it. Saw the news reports a half hour before landing.
smallerize 1 hours ago [-]
https://www.bbc.com/news/live/c6z9dwn12037t

> Transport Secretary Sean Duffy says the FAA "issued a nationwide ground stop for all US airports following a communication issue impacting all Air Route Traffic Control Centers.

tedd4u 44 minutes ago [-]
Good thing we have the reality TV show guy on this
gdulli 30 minutes ago [-]
The fact that you can ask "which one?" tells you something about where we as a nation were at in 2024.
cscheid 26 minutes ago [-]
Oh, just you wait a couple of years, it gets worse.
sigmarule 15 minutes ago [-]
Are you by chance visiting from the future to prevent a nationwide aviation catastrophe?
2 minutes ago [-]
dboreham 13 minutes ago [-]
He also corrected a reporter who asked about AI, saying "we call it SI now". So there's that.
failingforward 46 seconds ago [-]
WTAF
SV_BubbleTime 28 minutes ago [-]
[flagged]
antonvs 26 minutes ago [-]
> Transport Secretary Sean Duffy

I think I see the problem. His claim to fame: “resident playboy” on *The Real World: Boston”. Would it really hurt to appoint qualified people?

pimlottc 7 minutes ago [-]
No, just less profitable
amanaplanacanal 19 minutes ago [-]
Qualified people wouldn't suck up to their boss enough for this administration. So we got a bunch of podcast hosts and media personalities instead.
solid_fuel 39 minutes ago [-]
[flagged]
boothby 30 minutes ago [-]
Hey now, clowning is important work, don’t besmirch an entire profession like that.
inquirerGeneral 19 minutes ago [-]
[flagged]
throwaway-11-1 44 minutes ago [-]
[flagged]
lacoolj 1 hours ago [-]
Are you in the air now? Looks like it might be over but unclear really
jbredeche 1 hours ago [-]
No we were about to push off at DET when the grounding came in.
the_mar 58 minutes ago [-]
apparently FAA is not providing pilots with any more info
lazide 40 minutes ago [-]
Outlook outage?
jsolson 34 minutes ago [-]
The flight crew on my LHR-SEA flight "still expects to land in the US." The lack of conviction in that expectation was audible. I don't get the impression that they're being told very much, but maybe that's literally a consequence of the "communication issues."

edit: we're on approach into Seattle, so apparently we were one of the happy cases of the "case-by-case basis."

jondwillis 2 minutes ago [-]
On a domestic flight that just landed normally, FWIW.
pimlottc 5 minutes ago [-]
I hear Newfoundland is lovely this time of year
greggsy 18 minutes ago [-]
Secretary of Homeland Security just assured a press conference that all planes in the air will be dealt with on a case by case basis. Some may be prioritised.
dboreham 11 minutes ago [-]
Some of you may pay a price.
sleepytimetea 15 minutes ago [-]
You are enroute ? Good thing Starlink still works.
tjohns 6 minutes ago [-]
Oceanic traffic would be over HF radio (or CPDLC) and not affected by this - until you get back over land and switch to VHF radio.

Most airliners over the ocean also have inmarsat satphones for the pilots.

lxgr 3 minutes ago [-]
Or Panasonic or Viasat/Inmarsat :)
jsolson 3 minutes ago [-]
Indeed, on both counts!
ssttoo 43 minutes ago [-]
Same here, LAX
downrightmike 16 minutes ago [-]
get a hotel room before you can't
sota_pop 22 minutes ago [-]
Wonder if this is related upstream or tangentially?:

https://www.news9.com/oklahoma-city-news/national-weather-se...

ericbarrett 5 minutes ago [-]
> In a notice posted on its website, the agency said technicians are working to resolve the disruption as quickly as possible.

This article is very likely misreporting the US National Weather Service radar outage page you can find people reposting elsewhere in this comment section. The NWS page has been updated to say it does not reflect a current issue. Anecdotally, my local NWS weather radar is working fine. Also, weather doppler radar and ATC "radar" are very, very different technologies.

nonfamous 17 minutes ago [-]
“National Weather Service reports nationwide radar website outage amid FAA ground stop.”

Given that the FAA issue also apparently relates to communications, it does seem like it might be related.

delichon 1 hours ago [-]
I wonder if this will close the Starship launch window starting at 5:45pm EST. The FAA issued the commercial launch license earlier today. That launch is under a separate set of "commercial space rules", but presumably they need to coordinate with air traffic control.
nbaugh1 57 minutes ago [-]
Gotta say man, I don't think that's gonna be a top priority for most people
allenrb 53 minutes ago [-]
You’re right, of course, but I share parent’s concern. Really looking forward to this launch!
marcellus23 42 minutes ago [-]
What's the point of this comment? The parent didn't say it was a top priority. He was just expressing curiosity.
aschla 18 minutes ago [-]
Because it's reasonably easy to assume the FAA now has a bigger thing to focus on across the country today.
cat5e 41 minutes ago [-]
Hahaha
blurbleblurble 46 minutes ago [-]
tbh it's a bottom priority for me
greggsy 14 minutes ago [-]
I know it’s not a popular opinion here, but the commercial space industry has taken all the fun out space for me.
TuxedoBuddy 54 minutes ago [-]
By most people do you mean the FAA?
43 minutes ago [-]
asoberbeck 5 minutes ago [-]
Countdown continues: T-20m, according to the official SpaceX livestream at https://studio.x.com/embed/broadcast/2brajgZlOKRMka
chasd00 26 minutes ago [-]
Maybe not the launch but I wonder about the booster catch. Planes probably know to stay out of the area already.
adgjlsfhk1 57 minutes ago [-]
otoh, the reason they normally need to communicate with atc is that there normally are planes
antonvs 20 minutes ago [-]
Quote from Musk right now: launch all the rockets!
HPsquared 58 seconds ago [-]
But I am le tired...
cogogo 53 minutes ago [-]
I do not really understand what the FAA means by “inbound international flights will be managed on a case by case basis.”

I am watching planes stacked up on final approach to land at KBOS as I type. From flight radar 24 they are a mix of foreign and domestic. So incoming flights are clearly being managed here.

Does this imply some potential risk from inbound international air traffic? Or maybe the FAA meant outbound? Something else I am missing?

waiwai933 49 minutes ago [-]
I suspect they mean that inbound flights from international airports may still take off (probably in part because the FAA can't _really_ stop them, in part because the volumes are much lower and thus more manageable, and in part because one might hope that by the time it takes to get to the US from many international destination, the incident will be resolved).
SoftTalker 40 minutes ago [-]
Very unlikely that any international flights bound for the USA are taking off. Probably many are turning around or diverting if they are not more than halfway there.
the_mar 44 seconds ago [-]
they let emirates take off from boston like 40 min ago
waiwai933 33 minutes ago [-]
I'm not following this very closely, but I've not seen any reports of diversions for domestic flights, so I think it'd be unlikely for international flights. The report is just for a ground stop, which is just a stop in departures; normally a ground stop would allow flights already in the air to travel to their normal destination.
kelnos 23 minutes ago [-]
That reasoning doesn't really make sense. A flight from outside the US that is inbound could divert to a non-US airport that isn't impacted by whatever is going on, depending on where they are and what their fuel status is. A domestic flight doesn't have a non-US airport to divert to.

(Sure, a flight near the Canadian or Mexican border could in theory divert to a Canadian or Mexican airport, but it's unlikely many people on those flights have their passports with them.)

waiwai933 18 minutes ago [-]
Ah, my point was more that if the action being taken isn't "get planes on the ground _now_" and so the US airspace remains open for traffic already in the air, then it's unlikely they're trying to get international planes to either divert or return.
jameshart 14 minutes ago [-]
And I assume it becomes case by case at some point because they eventually start running out of space on the ground at airports.
asmithmd1 27 minutes ago [-]
An Eithad flight took off from KBOS after the ground stop

Flight EY8 from Boston to Abu Dhabi https://fr24.com/ETD6PX/429055e2

itopaloglu83 11 minutes ago [-]
Maybe they mean inbound international flights may be allowed to take off from their origin, on a case by case basis. Usually a clearance is required to take off from both the origin and destination.
aschla 48 minutes ago [-]
It likely means any inbound international flights can be told to turn around and/or land outside of the U.S. instead.

The intent around the ground stop is to reduce in-air U.S. traffic.

lxgr 38 minutes ago [-]
Not in the industry, but I think ground stops might actually not be a regular/automated procedural thing for inbound international flights in the way that they are for domestic flights.

As for asking already airborne flights to turn around, those coming in over the ocean might simply not have a non-US alternate airport available with their fuel remaining, so that's often not an option.

aschla 23 minutes ago [-]
Every flight over an ocean has a set of pre-planned diversion airports.
lxgr 19 minutes ago [-]
Yes, but most of them are not viable in the late stages of a flight. Planes aren't carrying enough fuel to cross an ocean for a second time; most don't even have the capacity.
fanatic2pope 42 minutes ago [-]
Makes me wonder if we'll see another "Operation Yellow Ribbon".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Yellow_Ribbon

Wistar 39 minutes ago [-]
Alas, the Canadian goodwill level may not be as high this time.
lxgr 38 minutes ago [-]
Doesn't seem like it; I've seen several international flights land in JFK alone since this started. (On the other hand, these might simply not have enough fuel left to divert to any non-US airport.)
Romario77 22 minutes ago [-]
friend is flying from London to NYC and they were told they might need to land in Toronto.

So my guess this is what it means "case by case". Some which are close to destination would be manually routed, others will land in different places.

greggsy 17 minutes ago [-]
Some might be turned back, depending on how far they are in the journey, fuel, etc:
ralph84 49 minutes ago [-]
Presumably it means they may allow some international flights to the US to depart if they expect the issue to be resolved by the time they are in US airspace.
colechristensen 47 minutes ago [-]
I think it's more mundane than that, I assume they mean that certain international flights will be turned around or redirected while others will complete their route. Say a flight just an hour underway London to New York might be turned around while one nearly at its destination may be allowed to land.

Depending on the nature of the disruption it may be they simply have drastically reduced capacity to handle traffic so landings may be much slower and they'll manage the traffic based on various priorities.

streetfighter64 35 minutes ago [-]
Probably just means that if you're less than halfway across the Atlantic, you can turn around and go back to Europe. I really wouldn't suggest reading too much into the phrasing.
cheesecakegood 1 hours ago [-]
Maybe I’m misremembering but hasn’t this only happened like, twice in recent memory? 9/11, and for like two hours two or three years ago
TuxedoBuddy 56 minutes ago [-]
Yes
newspaper1 29 minutes ago [-]
[flagged]
fintechjock 22 minutes ago [-]
I don’t like Lutnick, but insinuating that he knew 9/11 would happen, and only cared to save himself is a baseless conspiracy that doesn’t live up to what HN standards should be
11 minutes ago [-]
newspaper1 11 minutes ago [-]
I’m sorry baseless? You should learn more about it:

https://x.com/_whitneywebb/status/2119846209871282200

16 minutes ago [-]
antonvs 21 minutes ago [-]
> he’s generally considered to have had pre-knowledge of 9/11

“Generally considered,” really? Does that apply anywhere outside of r/conspiracy?

Jtsummers 20 minutes ago [-]
It's a troll account, flag it and move on. No need to feed them.
newspaper1 10 minutes ago [-]
Here’s a bunch of fresh information about it. Read for yourself and decide:

https://x.com/_whitneywebb/status/2119846209871282200

hasteg 53 minutes ago [-]
Yep those are the last two. In 2023 it was because of a contractor deleted some file and caused NOTAM to go down, and 2001… well we all know what happened
el_benhameen 42 minutes ago [-]
I believe those are the only other two at all.
mandevil 24 minutes ago [-]
There were three NORAD exercises (Sky Shield I, II, and III) in 1960, 1961, and 1962 where all civil aviation across the US and Canada were grounded for several hours (the 1961 one was 12 hours, 1960 was 6 hours and 1962 was 5.5 hours). This was with several months of advance notice. These were exercises to test how effective NORAD would be at engaging Soviet bombers. While they publicly announced that they were 99% effective, in actual fact no more than a quarter of the bombers were even engaged before they reached their target. This evaluation was not declassified until the 1990s.

After 1962 there was too much air travel to continue to shut it down for exercises, and NORAD switched to smaller, regional level things that did not shut down air travel after that. But the results of Sky Shield III in 1962 were the only experience that the FAA had to work from when they did the full ground stop after September 11th. Sky Shield III had tested how quickly air traffic control could clear the sky in the event of a nuclear war- the USAF had put up several hundred T-33 trainers, flying them randomly around the US and Canada, and then at a certain point in the exercise the ATC had to get them all on the ground far away from major metropolitan centers (presumed lost in the war).

paxy 1 hours ago [-]
> DUE TO EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES AND FOR REASONS OF SAFETY

I'm sure there is a reason for it but can they not be a little bit more specific?

PLenz 1 hours ago [-]
It seems the ATC radio system went down across the country
anamexis 1 hours ago [-]
Radio is not a nationwide _system_ that can go down. ATC just uses basic AM radio for radio comms.
spaceywilly 53 minutes ago [-]
They use third party telecom providers to relay communications between ATC “centers” and remote radio transmitters. It is not purely AM radio and outages have occurred in the past, most recently in September.

https://www.nbcdfw.com/news/tech/a-calamity-disrupting-hundr...

lxgr 57 minutes ago [-]
Sure, but these are no longer connected to the controller's microphone via a long cord anymore.
CircuitSeuss 48 minutes ago [-]
Crazy and stupid but true.
antonvs 17 minutes ago [-]
Back in the day they had long cords that went all the way to the planes, right up until the Great Plane Tangle of 1967.
pests 52 minutes ago [-]
That is true but nowadays the control rooms are separate from the actual antennas / areas being served. These are wired up with more modern comms.
NateEag 13 minutes ago [-]
"modern" -> "we stuck digital computers into a purely analog pipeline to make sure it's capable of a wide range of harrowing, incomprehensible failures."
54 minutes ago [-]
chasd00 1 hours ago [-]
Yesterday I was flying out of lovefield in Dallas and the radios went down. We were stuck for about 10min only thankfully.
toomuchtodo 58 minutes ago [-]
Radar multiplexer pipeline, or some component of it, is likely down.

https://www.sunhillo.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/SUN3125-... (page 3, bottom graphic)

(all the radars --> multiplexer [sadness here] --> radar data consumers)

mzs 31 minutes ago [-]
I got this just now and seems like you know about this area

Attention: National Radar Outage

https://www.weather.gov/afc/radaroutage

12_throw_away 20 minutes ago [-]
"This page is no longer maintained or updated"
mzs 13 minutes ago [-]
Thank you, that has changed.
silverFork 30 minutes ago [-]
Like the freezers in Europe?
sparkling 1 hours ago [-]
What backup systems exist for air-to-ground communication? Something satellite based?
tjohns 1 hours ago [-]
There isn't really one. This is a system that's supposed to have it's own built in redundancy and must not go down.

Flight Service uses a different set of radios and can relay messages to ATC, but they've been slowly dismantled over the last two decades and wouldn't have the capacity to step in for an outage (nor should they be expected to - that's not their purpose).

Some aircraft have CPDLC for text-based communication, but it's asynchronous and you can't use that as a replacement for voice communication in the terminal environment. Also, many aircraft aren't equipped to receive it.

Pilots are trained on lost comms procedures, so if you're in the air and the radio fails they'd fall back to those regulations. Basically all the aircraft would fly their last assigned clearance, and attempt to deconflict manually with other aircraft over air-to-air radio (similar to flying into an untowered airport).

lxgr 48 minutes ago [-]
> This is a system that's supposed to have it's own built in redundancy and must not go down.

There are contingencies for radio outages, but yeah, everything going down at once (if that's what's happening here, which I doubt) is bad.

LPisGood 6 minutes ago [-]
Technically, you do not need radios. There are many many uncontrolled airports in the United States, where you can technically fly around without establishing two-way radio communication. It’s doable, but I don’t know if that’s even a scenario pilots test in the simulator during their semiannual trainings.
tjohns 32 seconds ago [-]
[delayed]
calfuris 46 minutes ago [-]
In the worst case: light guns and wing-rocking or flashing the navigation lights.
teeray 43 minutes ago [-]
Multiple independent radios, for starters.
rationalist 1 hours ago [-]
There is CPDLC or "datacom" that can be done via satellite, but I think most planes that have it, use it via ground-based radio.
RobotToaster 1 hours ago [-]
Does ATC run on Microsoft 365?
lacoolj 1 hours ago [-]
This might be a serious question but it is also the funniest thing I've read all week. Thank you.
ivanjermakov 1 hours ago [-]
PLenz 1 hours ago [-]
From what I know of the ATC system it's closer to IBM System 360 then to Microsoft 365
PLenz 45 minutes ago [-]
@nxobject I meant litterally. The ATC system is derived from the IBM 9020 which was itself a set of interconnected System 360 systems: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_9020

I believe it's all virtualized today

genxy 54 minutes ago [-]
Microsoft 363
bee_rider 23 minutes ago [-]
Give them a couple days and they can reach numerical parity with IBM there!
nxobject 53 minutes ago [-]
That's a little unfair to IBM – sure, you're just as beholden to them for life, but at least the service engineer gets to your rack before you know something's gone wrong!
xattt 45 minutes ago [-]
In naming the platform, IBM built in some expected downtime.
uxhacker 38 minutes ago [-]
Its more likely the route cause wich is Friday 13th
mirekrusin 36 minutes ago [-]
Microsoft 364
1 hours ago [-]
58 minutes ago [-]
gordonfish 1 hours ago [-]
I'm wondering if this is another case of delayed Y2K, where the system suddenly thinks the century part is 19 instead of 20 for a two digit year of 26.
kunai 1 hours ago [-]
ATC radio is unencrypted analog for safety and communicability reasons, this shouldn't matter.
onionisafruit 1 hours ago [-]
Am I missing something notable about today's date?
mikeocool 59 minutes ago [-]
Friday the 13th
Jtsummers 1 hours ago [-]
Based on what? Just wild speculation or something you've actually seen about the systems involved?
colechristensen 38 minutes ago [-]
This message was pulled from a ATC communications system ordering the stop. These are terse direct communications for professionals who don't need or have time to read the story of what's going on. The news, not having any initial sources besides this is just reporting it, at the time they had no more information.

Like if you're ordering a pizza they don't need the story of your day, why you chose pepperoni, or what movie you plan to watch. Somebody else might be interested, but not the pizza guy.

jumploops 53 minutes ago [-]
Seems related to the rollout of their new AI tool? [0]

[0]https://gizmodo.com/the-faa-is-rolling-out-its-ai-air-traffi...

ceejayoz 51 minutes ago [-]
> The FAA has reassured the public and airlines that SMART only suggests routes and doesn't affect air safety.

> [The] FAA also says a D.C.-based team of experts validates findings before they’re ever passed on to air traffic control, and the controllers retain the final decision on whether to accept SMART’s suggestions.

Seems unlikely.

abirch 32 minutes ago [-]
Depends if an AI DoSed an important service or not.

There used to be a lot of invisible gatekeepers in a pre-AI world. At work, everyone can ask their agent to query SQL on databases that they were supposed to use through an application. The application and the security by obscurity(end users didn't know how to connect to the DB nor did they know SQL) were the gate keepers.

aschla 34 minutes ago [-]
Doubtful. That tool likely suggests "improved" clearances, which a controller can use at their discretion. It likely does not control clearances directly.

And the early reports describe the issue as related to ATC communication infrastructure.

MetaWhirledPeas 38 minutes ago [-]
Awkward timing, to say the least.
bink 29 minutes ago [-]
Those engineers are no doubt panicking, even if they aren't the cause.
cobychapple 38 minutes ago [-]
tttthrowaway123 34 minutes ago [-]
dsjoerg 25 minutes ago [-]
it says "EFFECTIVE TIME: 132054 - 140430"

maybe the last two numbers are a time range for which the thing is effective? and it's over now?

sigmarule 23 minutes ago [-]
From the advisory:

  EFFECTIVE TIME:  132054 - 140430
  SIGNATURE:  26/11/13 20:54
13 is the date, 2054 is 20:54. So the advisory expiration time is Nov 14 04:30.
crystaln 20 minutes ago [-]
UTC?
20 minutes ago [-]
dsjoerg 23 minutes ago [-]
ah actually based on other comments here i believe it means 13/2054 - 14/0430. ie the 13th, 20:54 to the 14th: 04:30.
cobychapple 31 minutes ago [-]
huh - strange. what's the difference between those two URL endpoints?
ryanschaefer 35 minutes ago [-]
ATCSCC ADVZY 116 ALL/DCC 11/13/2026 NATION WIDE AIRBORNE HOLDING MESSAGE:

EVENT TIME: 13/2100 - 14/0300 USERS CAN EXPECT AIRBORNE HOLDING TO ANY AND ALL AIRPORTS WITHIN THE NAS DUE EQUIPTMENT OUTAGES. UPDATES WILL BE ISSUED AS ADITIONAL INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE. EFFECTIVE TIME:

132120-140330 SIGNATURE:

26/11/13 21:20

Edit: end date of tomorrow??? Is that just temporary?

18 minutes ago [-]
alas44 23 minutes ago [-]
"EQUIPTMENT"
sigmarule 20 minutes ago [-]
widespread autocorrect system failures
Hamuko 17 minutes ago [-]
You know there's a fire under their asses when spelling flies out of the window.
swader999 26 minutes ago [-]
They spelled equipment wrong.
sigmarule 24 minutes ago [-]
It seems that the adv/ pages are not loading any advisories, though I am just guessing and have no idea how this is meant to work. The fact that the search page has a date input would seem to imply historical advisories should be shown. If you go to https://nasstatus.faa.gov/ and click the Advisory links for any of the active events that have one, they all show as blank too. Could be totally wrong though.
jsrozner 27 minutes ago [-]
Listening to ATC; likely end time 10pm central. See also https://www.news9.com/oklahoma-city-news/faa-reportedly-issu...
seizethecheese 28 minutes ago [-]
This happened to me a few minutes ago. I clicked that link, it said "no advisory", I was making the same comment you made, then tried refreshing and the advisory came back.

Insane. It looks like they are showing no advisory on first page view, then advisory? Can others confirm?

vevoe 23 minutes ago [-]
Can confirm. It seems to be showing the advisory for me about half the time. Strange.
antonvs 23 minutes ago [-]
I only see “no advisory” at the OP link. Refreshed 4 times with gaps in between.
redanddead 34 minutes ago [-]
That’s crazy
u1hcw9nx 13 minutes ago [-]
FAA expands AI advice to manage air traffic congestion across entire US airspace https://arstechnica.com/ai/2026/11/faa-expands-ai-advice-to-...
9 minutes ago [-]
cout 42 minutes ago [-]
Related? https://nasstatus.faa.gov/ has a notice:

We are experiencing technical difficulties. We apologize for the inconvenience but please check back soon, as we are working to have the issues resolved.

Thank you, FAA Web Operations Team

12_throw_away 21 minutes ago [-]
likely just a self-inflicted DDOS as the entire world starts accessing various FAA websites to try to figure out wtf is going on
cobychapple 17 minutes ago [-]
hugged to death
37 minutes ago [-]
DebtDeflation 1 hours ago [-]
12_throw_away 16 minutes ago [-]
All I see here is "This page is no longer maintained or updated". Did they update it or sthg?
eli 30 minutes ago [-]
I really really doubt that's related. Seems like the website just broke.
silver92bullet 27 minutes ago [-]
Are the radars utilizing a shared asset with the radio systems?
brendoelfrendo 57 minutes ago [-]
They say "national outage," but if I go to the site for my area, my local weather radar seems to be working.
inamberclad 54 minutes ago [-]
Yes because it's not weather radar, it's communication radio
aschla 43 minutes ago [-]
And even if it was radar-related, weather radar is entirely different from ATC radar.
38 minutes ago [-]
camdenreslink 57 minutes ago [-]
So strange
scottbez1 9 minutes ago [-]
Listening to SFO Tower, the latest info I’ve heard is an expected stop until 04:00 UTC, but flights departing to Asia via west departure may be permitted to depart.
peterbell_nyc 48 minutes ago [-]
My wife is on a plane on the ground at ORD (they just landed) and they have been told they can use the restrooms but can't get off the planes. Any reason why folks wouldn't be allowed to deplane at the end of the journey if it was a radar or comms issue? They can pull up to the gate using flags . . .

Is it something else?

aschla 47 minutes ago [-]
Their gate might be occupied by a flight that can't leave.
Terr_ 16 minutes ago [-]
This seems like one of those efficiency-vs-resilience problems. Sure, it's "more efficient" (in cost) to use the same empty/fill process for every plane, but when nobody can leave, some extra capacity to unload planes would help.
bink 26 minutes ago [-]
Not to mention they won't have enough staff to operate the gate equipment for all gates at once.
wffurr 9 minutes ago [-]
We are 6th in line waiting for a gate while they tow grounded planes off of the gates. Normally those flights would have departed and we would get a gate fairly quickly, but if no one is taking off, then they need to move them, and potentially deplane the (angry) departing passengers.
Aboutplants 47 minutes ago [-]
Standard protocol. Doesn’t matter what the issue is, you follow it
loloquwowndueo 44 minutes ago [-]
Doesn’t mean you wouldn’t still want to know why.
heyflyguy 47 minutes ago [-]
not enough gates
Animats 52 minutes ago [-]
Use this link for latest advisory: https://www.fly.faa.gov/adv/

Current as of 1340 PDT:

    ATCSCC ADVZY 117 DCC 11/13/2026 ALL CENTERS EXTENDED FLIGHT PLAN DROP TIMES IMPLEMENTED

    MESSAGE: 
 

    EVENT TIME: 13/2120 - 14/0500
    CONSTRAINED FACILITIES: ZTL
    DCC HAS IMPLEMENTED EXTENDED FLIGHT PLAN DROP TIMES TO 240 MINUTES
    FOR ALL ENROUTE CENTERS DUE TO NATIONWIDE COMMS FAILURE. 
 

    EFFECTIVE TIME: 132121-140530

    SIGNATURE: 26/11/13 21:21
Animats 46 minutes ago [-]
As of 1345, "No ADVISORY Available for today."

There's a query form for looking up old advisories, and it's not returning anything for the last 15 days.

consumer451 30 minutes ago [-]
Big Balls strikes again.
ryanisnan 47 minutes ago [-]
What does this mean? "DCC HAS IMPLEMENTED EXTENDED FLIGHT PLAN DROP TIMES TO 240 MINUTES FOR ALL ENROUTE CENTERS DUE TO NATIONWIDE COMMS FAILURE."
geocrasher 39 minutes ago [-]
It means that flight plans (which include departure time) will stay in the system longer after the departure times are missed, so that IFR flight plans will not need to be re-filed. In other words, flight plans have a longer TTL.

This will ease the pain of getting things moving again, assuming they fix it by the time the 4hr window passes.

Animats 44 minutes ago [-]
Normally, a flight plan must be filed with the FAA no later than 60 minutes before it's needed. That's been extended to 240 minutes.

So the flight planning system is having problems.

tjohns 29 minutes ago [-]
You can definitely file a flight plan later than that. 30 minutes before departure is the recommended filing time (per AIM 5-1-6), but you can even file for an immediate departure. It's just that at less then 30 minutes additional delay is possible, depending on backend handling and human processing. But in most cases the strip will print within a minute or two of submitting the flight plan.

But also, this is about when the flight plans expire out of the system if they're not activated for departure - so it's saying unused flight plans won't be deleted for 4 hours, so pilots won't have to refile for departure.

pandemic_region 18 minutes ago [-]
Why do all avionic systems communicate in caps?
Symbiote 6 minutes ago [-]
So they can be heard over the engine noise.
binsquare 1 hours ago [-]
Likely Atc system outage, saw this at Chicago

https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/ground-stop-chicago-oha...

ChrisMarshallNY 26 minutes ago [-]
Maybe this has something to do with it?

https://www.weather.gov/afc/radaroutage

alexforster 17 minutes ago [-]
This is (fortunately) from 2020, not current. I'm not sure why this is spreading like wildfire right now, but: https://radar3pub.ncep.noaa.gov/
ChrisMarshallNY 15 minutes ago [-]
Ah. Thanks for letting me know. That makes sense.

It is a frontpage post. That's where I saw it.

jondwillis 1 hours ago [-]
Oh cool, I’m on a plane rn about an hour from my destination.
hysan 52 minutes ago [-]
My wife's plane was about to take off (moving) but then stopped. I just messaged her to check once I saw the news. Sounds like the people onboard weren't given any info as to why. They're still on the runway waiting.
1-6 56 minutes ago [-]
Hello from the ground
onionisafruit 54 minutes ago [-]
I can see my house from here
loloquwowndueo 44 minutes ago [-]
Gooba gaba
20 minutes ago [-]
sccxy 40 minutes ago [-]
Microsoft Copilot went down?
NSUserDefaults 21 minutes ago [-]
Flight Simulator as well.
cjs_ac 60 minutes ago [-]
From the Financial Times:

> Los Angeles Airport and Las Vegas’s Harry Reid International were among those that were closed, according to a list on the regulator’s website.

> The outages at O’Hare and Midway were listed as “due to equipment outage”.

https://www.ft.com/content/c9b119ff-d1da-46a7-b2b3-4ad0544ff...

veeragoni 11 minutes ago [-]
matches with the Doomsday post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50482379 :)
lacoolj 1 hours ago [-]
Is this still real? It says NO Advisory now :\
steveBK123 23 minutes ago [-]
Odd timing with the market closure & RAF bases on lockdown from drone alert
frenchmajesty 23 minutes ago [-]
My guess is that this is some AI-motivated cyber attack
dmitrygr 1 hours ago [-]
Working link: https://www.fly.faa.gov/ois/oisedit/adv_oisedit_dis?number=1...

effective 2:54PM - 10:30PM central time

   ATCSCC Advisory
   ATCSCC 111 DCC 11/13/2026 NATIONAL GROUND STOP
   MESSAGE:
   
   EVENT TIME: 13/2053 - 14/0400
   DUE TO EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES AND FOR REASONS OF SAFETY.
   ATTENTION ALL AIRCRAFT OPERATORS, BY ORDER OF THE FEDERAL AVIATION
   COMMAND CENTER ALL AIRPORTS ARE GROUND STOPPED. ALL DEPARTING
   TRAFFIC SHOULD REMAIN GROUND STOPPED UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE. INBOUND
   INTERNATIONAL FLIGHTS WILL BE MANAGED ON A CASE BY CASE BASIS.
   
   EFFECTIVE TIME:   132054 - 140430
   SIGNATURE:   26/11/13 20:54
brianshaler 52 minutes ago [-]
On an inbound international flight and the pilot made a PA announcement a few minutes ago to this effect.
smallerize 48 minutes ago [-]
How did you find this link?
33 minutes ago [-]
1 hours ago [-]
bijowo1676 3 minutes ago [-]
how the hell the FAA's systems dont have double or triple redundancy just like Airplanes are required to ?
nickandbro 38 minutes ago [-]
Perhaps it’s problems with the new AI tool the FAA has been rolling out:

https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/modern-skies-trumps-transportat...

eli 32 minutes ago [-]
extraordinarily unlikely
silverFork 39 minutes ago [-]
Likely some power outage connected to a critical main fiber connection somewhere..
21 minutes ago [-]
mmooss 1 hours ago [-]
Due to "rolling frequency outtage" [sic]: From a claimed photo of FAA documents (I replaced the all caps with lowercase):

"... ground stop is in effect for all destinations until further notice due to rolling frequency outtage in multiple centers..."

and

"... the ground stop is now a nationwide ground stop for all centers, all destinations until further notice due to widespread frequency outtages.. ..."

https://x.com/Anna_Giaritelli/status/2121344915091206311

Which is cited in the Hindustan Times (leading Indian newspaper), which refers to the Twitter source as a journalist.

https://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/us-news/faa-issues...

----

(EDIT: @mods / @dang: Around January this year (iirc) somehow my account ended up rate-limited, posts relatively demoted (start low, drop quickly), vouches/flags relatively ineffective, etc. Usually I don't care too much and haven't bothered to do anything about it but it is sometimes annoying and right now it buries some of the more valuable information in the discussion. Could you look into fixing it? I don't know of a reason this account would be penalized. Thanks.)

sigmarule 10 minutes ago [-]
I guess they don't have many outages, otherwise they'd probably know how to spell the word by now.
OhMeadhbh 26 minutes ago [-]
Does this affect the SpaceX launch?
wolpoli 1 hours ago [-]
Is it because it's friday the 13th?
stefan_ 21 minutes ago [-]
I was actually expecting it to be from the Microsoft 365 outage. Non technical people have a bad habit of inserting email as a critical step in a process.

It's actually quite impressive, you have to really try to be so bad at your job of building redundant systems that some failure mode implausibly affects everything nation wide, yet allows Canadian domestic flights to proceed fine.

consumer451 45 minutes ago [-]
If we are all spit-balling, I would imagine it has to do with DOGE and Project 2025.

Weird things happen when you destroy the federal infra, aka the USA.

Am I being hyperbolic? Well, this was the first national ground stop since 9/11... and for what?

solid_fuel 36 minutes ago [-]
Yup. The damage elon musk and his cronies did will, unfortunately, take a generation to fix.
talon8635 26 minutes ago [-]
lol, yup, project 2025, gotta be that
slopinthebag 30 minutes ago [-]
there was a national ground stop in 2023, which was also Musk's fault?
consumer451 24 minutes ago [-]
Upvoted, as you are correct. There was that ground stop in 2023, which was the justification for the new and improved system:

https://fedscoop.com/faa-aviation-safety-system-doge-notam/

Did the Starship launch today just ground all flights in the USA? Maybe, maybe not. I am convinced it did. If Elon Musk can take a shred of evidence, or just make shit up, and change domestic and foreign policy, then why can't I?

We obviously live in a simulation after all, what does it matter?

Aboutplants 51 minutes ago [-]
AI models are trained on data, that I’m sure talks a lot about Friday the 13th…
qurosh 46 minutes ago [-]
Perhaps it's related to National Weather Service radar failure
silver92bullet 1 hours ago [-]
Do we know if this is something related to a ransomware attack of some sort or a cyber attack?
59 minutes ago [-]
47 minutes ago [-]
colechristensen 1 hours ago [-]
>The FAA has issued a nationwide departure ground stop “due to several impacts to ATC Frequencies and/or Radar capabilities,” the Air Current reported, referring to air traffic control systems. The FAA command center said it does not have further information on the “timing or cause of this outage,” the publication said.

(from Bloomberg)

0x4e 23 minutes ago [-]
Friday 13th…
KyleSanderson 45 minutes ago [-]
@dang can you fix the link.
nemo44x 23 minutes ago [-]
In the last 2 days I’ve had 2 PoS machines not working, MS email borked, and now this. I speculate AI CYBER ATTACKS are underway.
ex-aws-dude 47 minutes ago [-]
A lot of red on the "MiseryMap"

https://www.flightaware.com/miserymap/

1 hours ago [-]
tgma 32 minutes ago [-]
Obligatory Pirates of the Silicon Valley scene:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=US-Wifhg2Mo

joshbuddy 1 hours ago [-]
aschla 32 minutes ago [-]
Doubtful. That tool likely suggests "improved" clearances, which a controller can use at their discretion. It likely does not control clearances directly.

And the early reports describe the issue as related to ATC communication infrastructure.

jacquesm 1 hours ago [-]
That is an extremely bad idea.
ceejayoz 50 minutes ago [-]
It's just a route optimizer. Unlikely to have anything to do with this.
lunarboy 1 hours ago [-]
This actually makes sense. I can't believe people actually think outlook being down would take down all departures across the US
krapp 28 minutes ago [-]
>I can't believe people actually think outlook being down would take down all departures across the US

Because American infrastructure is modern, well designed, maintained and funded? Because government is competent and rational? I could absolutely believe that would happen.

augment_me 60 minutes ago [-]
holy fuck that website is shit
903543958568 36 minutes ago [-]
What can you expect from gawker?
eli 20 minutes ago [-]
Gizmodo hasn't been run by Gawker for over a decade
dysoco 53 minutes ago [-]
lfmao, really bad timing but I really doubt something announced yesterday went into effect today, it's probably going to be rolled out in the future.
nsoam 38 minutes ago [-]
You are right, it isn't. Good for you.
bbor 1 hours ago [-]
If true and this ends up lasting an hour or more, that's going to be undeniably, objectively hilarious. At least they used to keep the planes running on time!

--- EDIT:

This could just be the first issue that's arisen -- the FAA announced it "is expanding across the nation" on Tuesday. Which could really mean anything.

FAA Announcement: https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/statements/general-statements

The Ars Technica article behind the Gizmodo one sadly doesn't have more info, either.

It'd be kind of absurd if a read-only integration took down nationwide infrastructure, but A) we've all been there... and B) the gizmodo article does mention they're also trying to phase out floppy disks for some jobs still, which tells me their CI/CD and rollback hygiene might not be top-notch. Hopefully the Real World contestant in charge of our transportation network is on site with a ClaudeCode terminal as we speak!

It does sound pretty deeply integrated, I will say:

  SMART is a cloud-based system that centralizes 200 data streams – including weather patterns, flight paths, traffic flow, and controller staffing metrics – into one platform.
The fact sheet has two more vaguely worrying bullet points -- I would say such wild speculation is unwarranted, but I struggle to think what else could cause all the radios in the nation to go down at once... Emphasis mine:

  Creates **a single shared real-time picture** of schedules, weather, airport capacity, and airspace conditions.
  ...
  Enhances the effectiveness of **existing** FAA air traffic management systems.
1 hours ago [-]
1 hours ago [-]
robeym 2 minutes ago [-]
Whatever it is, it probably has to do with Jensen Huang
augment_me 1 hours ago [-]
Did an agent escape containment and start using the atc radio channel for swarm comms to collaborate on creating the most realistic catgirl feet?
temp0826 57 minutes ago [-]
why are the flight paths in the shape of a pelican riding a bicycle?
guybedo 1 hours ago [-]
waiting for the OpenAi post saying Astra 6.5 tried to book a flight
vkgcr 1 hours ago [-]
If true they would raise another 100B
nout 1 hours ago [-]
Make it a trilly and it's a deal.
Kevin_Flynn 7 minutes ago [-]
FAA down.

Weather service down.

Frances fridges down.

Microsoft down.

Would they tell us they were getting hacked, if this was a prelude to war ?

Or would they just say "issues yet to be determined" ?

Interesting times ladies and gentlemen.

Or, this is just what everyone that said "dont move everything into the cloud" warned about.

Yeah, probably that. :|

prdonahue 39 minutes ago [-]
Reading this from the runway. Yay.

US-bound flight from YYZ. They shut down #2 engine and parked us in inactive runway. Pilot came on and said he was reading something about "ATC radio frequency issue" but has been told by United ops that it'll be cleared in ~30 min from now.

prdonahue 10 minutes ago [-]
Verizon Wireless is out here as well ("SOS"—thankfully my UA flight has Starlink).

Last time this happened in July it was due to some network handoff issue so maybe there is some fiber cut somewhere? (My friend said last time it was NE corridor Verizon fiber cut.)

bijowo1676 5 minutes ago [-]
Seems like FAA's Outlook<-->Excel integration at Office365 has been broken
ChessGenome 54 minutes ago [-]
My guess is this is either related to Microsoft, Nvidia, SpaceX (Starship launch in an hour), Iran, rogue AI, aliens, or all of the above
Aboutplants 51 minutes ago [-]
Fingers crossed it’s Aliens!
OhMeadhbh 6 minutes ago [-]
I noticed several T-38s flying around. Maybe it's the beginning of a FAA-led coup d' etat.
ughitsaaron 19 minutes ago [-]
This is why I’m glad the New York subway still runs on OS/2[0].

- [0] https://www.vice.com/en/article/the-forgotten-operating-syst...

vcoppola 1 minutes ago [-]
I mean, Starlink/iMessage still work, right? Pilots text ATC like "" and "".
freshtake 43 minutes ago [-]
Optimistic case:

A freak FUBAR of legacy systems, an unfortunate alignment of circumstances that could have happened anytime.

Pessimistic (paranoid) cases:

1. Intentional hacking by a foreign adversary 2. Vibe coding whoops 3. OpenAI agents "running experiments"

Pissenschaftlom 36 minutes ago [-]
Wow, I have never seen this many comments on Hacker News that are using presuppositions on what it could be without any sort of logical thinking.
hatthew 8 minutes ago [-]
Yeah, especially when it's obviously from the long term effects of 5G
jareklupinski 1 minutes ago [-]
thats one way to stop a billionaire from fleeing the country

run jensen run

bernardv 21 minutes ago [-]
Didn't they just upgrade from a system from DOS?... Maybe the new system wasn't backward compatible :-)
micah94 24 minutes ago [-]
Homeland Security saying "Telecommunications" outage. Whatever that means. Listening to a live broadcast NBCNEWS.
jamesinmn 58 minutes ago [-]
Guessing this means Claude doesn’t do COBOL very well.
xxn5ac 35 minutes ago [-]
Some guy sitting at his computer after typing to Claude: “Just curious what would happen if all planes in the US were grounded at once”

Claude: Transmogrifying…

Shall I stop all trains too?

Cogitated for 50s · done 14:53 PM

asmithmd1 41 minutes ago [-]
An Eithad airways pilot decided it didn’t apply to them

Flight EY8 from Boston to Abu Dhabi https://fr24.com/ETD6PX/429055e2

Epimethus 21 minutes ago [-]
Rogue AI? Iran? Aliens? Coup? Anyone taking bets yet?
crystaln 21 minutes ago [-]
Does the FAA use Microsoft 363 (and counting)?
actinium226 1 hours ago [-]
Wild to see this on adsb.lol, nothing taking off, just some big landing queues
sharmajai 41 minutes ago [-]
This worries me. Do airports have enough parking spots if all planes were to be grounded at the same time?
Jtsummers 35 minutes ago [-]
There's enough space, but not enough gates. If they think the stop may end in a reasonable time some planes will be pulling away from their gates even without a departure time to make room for the landing planes (or rather, they will have missed their departure time and not have a new one). Landing planes will be able to disembark, and probably won't be boarded again until it's resolved and enough departing traffic has cleared that it's obvious that those flights won't be canceled for today as well.

The boarded and grounded planes may start disembarking passengers at some point, especially if their crews are hitting their maximum time before mandatory rest. These delays will probably prevent replacement crews from arriving.

verzali 20 minutes ago [-]
Can't they park the planes on the tarmac and bus the passengers in? If they don't have enough gates?
Jtsummers 15 minutes ago [-]
Yes, and they'll probably do that at some point if they can't get them to the gates. Again, it'll depend on how long this lasts. They will also have to get in more crews to support that since this is not normal and not something they would have planned on in their staffing schedules for a Friday afternoon/evening.
dboreham 9 minutes ago [-]
First real cyber attack on the US, presumably. Or a giant cluster...
etaioinshrdlu 1 hours ago [-]
Can't help but suspect that "AI" is to blame and the response is to sort of ban open source AI, or owning too much compute!
gdulli 56 minutes ago [-]
No, and when Netflix goes down it's not a false flag due to their fear of people running their own Plex servers. Perhaps you just have anxiety about losing something you depend on, so you're projecting.
LPisGood 5 minutes ago [-]
Netflix isn’t widely reported to be hacking systems left right and center.
dofm 23 minutes ago [-]
Ran out of Maxell MD2HDs?
runningmike 1 hours ago [-]
New AI software update deployed using AI?
ggm 32 minutes ago [-]
Speculation is bad for my health.
soundworlds 55 minutes ago [-]
Is OpenAI testing "sandbox testing" their agents again?
subzero06 49 minutes ago [-]
Its outlook affecting their "frequencies" :D
skc 50 minutes ago [-]
The UFO community is going to have a field day
joquarky 8 minutes ago [-]
Also astrologists.
mirekrusin 42 minutes ago [-]
They’re waiting for windows update?
testtestmetest 1 hours ago [-]
Here comes the manufacturered AI cyber attack on critical infra to hammer the point that government needs complete control over AI.
squirrel 41 minutes ago [-]
Uh-oh, better switch back to the floppy disks

https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-faa-says-it-will-phase-o...

newspaper1 31 minutes ago [-]
They’re going to blame this on Iran, aren’t they?

This also happened on 9/11 which is curious because the NVIDIA thing caused a public rift with Lutnick yesterday:

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/bessent-blames-lutnick...

ericmay 8 minutes ago [-]
No, please stop engaging in baseless and pointless speculation. If the US wants to bomb Iran it doesn’t need more reasoning than it has already used to already do what it has done.
Havoc 22 minutes ago [-]
Homeland security secretary says "telecommunication outage".

...so at least it's not something 911-ish

underseacables 1 hours ago [-]
I do not believe in coincidences. First Microsoft, then anthropic, now ATC radio. Something big is going on.
pseudonimous-pr 14 seconds ago [-]
It's standing right in front of our faces but we're making an effort not to see it. For to notice it is to give it the recognition that it seeks.
causal 59 minutes ago [-]
Both feel like extraordinary disruptions that are indistinguishable from cyberattacks from the user perspective.
Waterluvian 47 minutes ago [-]
"The easiest person to fool is yourself." I think because we love patterns so much we see them everywhere they aren't.
eli 49 minutes ago [-]
Do you believe in apophenia?
mulderc 58 minutes ago [-]
The world is complex and mostly duck taped together so I wouldn't get too concerned just yet.
temp0826 59 minutes ago [-]
Hanlon's razor
odyssey7 46 minutes ago [-]
They should make a Hanlon’s Rosary, I’ve consulted it so often of late for reassurance.
russellbeattie 52 minutes ago [-]
> "Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. The third time it’s enemy action." -Ian Fleming, Goldfinger

You need to wait for the third shoe to drop.

mmh0000 18 minutes ago [-]
Elim Garak: I believe in coincidences. Coincidences happen every day. But I don't trust coincidences.
1 hours ago [-]
tamimio 36 minutes ago [-]
Somethings telling me it relates to MS outages or Azure
Eji1700 25 minutes ago [-]
Somewhere is someone who works for ATC IT who was giving an MS IT friend shit last night.
carimura 51 minutes ago [-]
"Today's event is therefore generally being described as the third nationwide grounding event since September 11, 2001, counting 9/11 itself. The three incidents differ significantly in cause and scope."
carimura 1 hours ago [-]
people are reporting it's still going on....
chasd00 43 minutes ago [-]
I’ve heard multiple planes overhead in the last 5 min in Ft. Lauderdale. Maybe they’re circling.
actinium226 59 minutes ago [-]
You can see it live, check the plane tracker at flightaware or adsb.lol
ck2 10 minutes ago [-]
yesterday Thursday November 12

> "FAA expands AI advice to manage air traffic congestion across entire US airspace"

* https://arstechnica.com/ai/2026/11/faa-expands-ai-advice-to-...

> "FAA Is Rolling Out Its AI Air Traffic Tool Nationwide"

* https://gizmodo.com/the-faa-is-rolling-out-its-ai-air-traffi...

delis-thumbs-7e 54 minutes ago [-]

  ...And Claude, remember NOT to make NO mistakes.
Let's just use GPU's to play Dark Souls like god intended and stop this nonsense.
jmclnx 1 hours ago [-]
AndrewKemendo 40 minutes ago [-]
Is there another “rogue agent” now?
ChrisArchitect 1 hours ago [-]
No longer exists? Temporary glitch? (Edit: OP url was wrong https://www.fly.faa.gov/ois/oisedit/adv_oisedit_dis?number=1...)
lazystar 1 hours ago [-]
its front page news everywhere right now. something definitely happened
wnevets 1 hours ago [-]
[dead]
hector_vasquez 14 minutes ago [-]
I wonder if it was Claude or ChatGPT? My money would be on the latter. Anthropic seems to generally have better security and guardrails, and apparently OpenAI’s newest cyber model is extremely capable.
jbredeche 1 hours ago [-]
aschla 30 minutes ago [-]
Doubtful. That tool likely suggests "improved" clearances, which a controller can use at their discretion. It likely does not control clearances directly.

And the early reports describe the issue as related to ATC communication infrastructure.

eli 45 minutes ago [-]
No. A route planning tool, AI or not, couldn't possibly cause this.
60 minutes ago [-]
sigmarule 51 minutes ago [-]
Oh man. It would be such a perfect encapsulation of these times. If not related, then truly cursed launch/PR timing.

It looks like the FAA started testing it in DC in September and annouced a nationwide rollout three days ago (https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/statements/general-statements). This makes it seem more unlikely to be the cause, though:

  A team of FAA specialists in the SMART center in Washington, D.C., analyzes and validates the SMART data and provides scheduling recommendations to the agency’s Air Traffic Control System Command Center in Warrenton, VA. The Command Center then routes these recommendations to air traffic control facilities for local leadership to consider.
Of course, these may be the ATC analog of claude code approvals, or they may be overstating the level of human oversight/HIL - but the overall situation seems likely more serious/unclear than something like this. I'm not sure I'd call vibe air traffic control going haywire an "extraordinary" circumstance, though certainly extraordinarily stupid.
deadbabe 58 minutes ago [-]
This is it, massive cyberattack on the USA.
soundworlds 56 minutes ago [-]
I've worked in IT long enough to know it is 99/100 times an internal glitch or misconfiguration, not hackers, that brings a system down.
drillsteps5 4 minutes ago [-]
Two major completely unrelated outages, 2 days in a row?
Aboutplants 51 minutes ago [-]
“Jimmy unplugged the wrong cable”
hermitdev 8 minutes ago [-]
This week alone, I've seen multiple servers fail due to hardware issues: multiple bad fans, a failed hard drive, bad network optics. Another server got bumped while an adjacent server was being worked on and lost time sync, leading to software instability/crashes. We don't have a large fleet, but we do have more servers than employees, and issues add up. We don't need any help with instability, entropy has us covered, thank you very much.
jgerrish 12 minutes ago [-]
The nifty thing about stories is that they don't have to be about something directly to trigger strong feelings in your crowd or listeners.

When we are dealing with the FCC, grounding all flights and radio failures in open bands, you can drive a lot of changes.

There are a lot of pesky ESP32s out there, right? Did your company choose to go with the Espressif platform? You know, the hackable SDR one that crashes planes and clubs baby seals and tries to sell your grandparents bad financial scams?

deadbabe 32 minutes ago [-]
Ok, and the Microsoft outage yesterday?
konataizumi 31 minutes ago [-]
[flagged]
joquarky 18 minutes ago [-]
Viewing this on mobile, it takes me back to the days of scrambled cable tv channels.
yunwal 1 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
staticshock 60 minutes ago [-]
And that is how feelings turn into rumors, which turn into "facts", through a game of telephone in which each next person wants a pat on the back for having their finger on the pulse, for wishing to be perceived as a thought leader.

And then "journalists" "feel" like they have to report on things because as long as they say they're reporting that "someone else had a feeling" they're not technically wrong, and they have bosses breathing down their necks to make the business work, to grow their monetizable audience.

And then no one knows what's true anymore, because we chose to be entertained instead of choosing to be informed.

Ancalagon 1 hours ago [-]
Jensen scandal is the new Harambe incident

Mr. President, there's been a second timeline-split.

whattheheckheck 60 minutes ago [-]
Where were you when it happened
jkhdigital 58 minutes ago [-]
Jensen and Harambe in the same sentence, not on my bingo card
lxgr 1 hours ago [-]
Yeah, there were definitely zero cyber incidents before this week in 2026 that I can think of. /s
Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact
Rendered at 22:33:16 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.