NHacker Next
  • new
  • past
  • show
  • ask
  • show
  • jobs
  • submit
County with 37 Data Centers Asks Schools to 'Conserve Electricity' (404media.co)
jonas21 26 minutes ago [-]
This is in Virgina, which passed the Virginia Clean Economy Act in 2020. This mandated that Dominion (the power company) transition to 100% renewable energy by 2045. Personally, I think this is a good thing in the long run, but in the short run, it means that Dominion has had to invest a lot in building out renewable projects that haven't come online yet.

Lawrence Berkeley National Lab recently did an analysis on electricity prices in the US [1] and found that most of the rate increase in Virginia was attributable to the VCEA, and that load growth had a mitigating effect on price increases.

And if you look at the overall report (not just Virginia), the places where electricty costs are rising the fastest are generally not the same places where lots of new datacenters are being built. It's easy to blame datacenters, but there are a lot of factors at play here.

[1] https://emp.lbl.gov/publications/factors-influencing-recent-...

toomuchtodo 4 minutes ago [-]
So don't allow data centers to connect until enough clean energy has been brought online to meet their needs without impacting cost or availability for retail ratepayers. It's easy really. Say no.

It's so strange to me that the argument previously was "we don't have enough energy generation for EVs and heat pumps to electrify and decarbon" but data centers are thought of as must run load that everyone has to suffer in some way to enable (through increased rates or risk of blackouts), when they have very little positive impact for everyone except a small minority investing in them.

> It's easy to blame datacenters, but there are a lot of factors at play here.

It is because they are the problem. We need as much clean energy as quickly as possible to mitigate climate change, we do not need data centers, broadly speaking.

(if you replaced all of the farmland/ag land, the size of the state of Oregon, harvested for ethanol with solar, you would have more electrical generation than all current US electrical generation combined as of this comment)

scottndecker 59 minutes ago [-]
If everyone turned off their lights 100% of the time they left their workstation, they could power those additional data centers for about one second.
burnte 47 minutes ago [-]
Billionaries are willing to have us make that sacrifice!
imhoguy 8 minutes ago [-]
Turn off computers and phones. No need for DCs then.
hakunin 29 minutes ago [-]
Just use smart lights that feed video into an llm to check if lights should shut down.
skeeter2020 45 minutes ago [-]
not to mention you'll get much farther, faster & easier with timers on the lights than some sort of 100% voluntary participation dream.
dylan604 38 minutes ago [-]
ever been in a room of people sitting in cubicles where the lights are controlled by motion sensor to automatically turn off the lights after a set period of no motion? fun times. it took way longer to get that switch replaced than it should have
emsign 41 minutes ago [-]
"Who needs public schools anyway? I pay my kid's teachers salary directly."
sokoloff 17 minutes ago [-]
Those aren’t the same unit.

“Everyone turned off their lights” relates to power.

“Power datacenters for one second” relates to energy.

cwillu 12 minutes ago [-]
You dropped the time component from the first, so yes, the result is incomparable.

“Power spent on lighting worstations while vacant” is energy

Dr_Emann 2 minutes ago [-]
I don't think so, "while vacant" is an infinite amount of time, if you look infinitely far into the future.
17 minutes ago [-]
zamadatix 41 minutes ago [-]
I think the issues are exacerbated by the US going from "regular growth in electricity generation" for decades to "dead flat" for the last ~2 decades. I think we're finding generation isn't just a switch you turn on and reap the benefits of overnight if it's not what you were already planning on doing https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/e...

Part of solving that may be in what the article touches on - how to get the generation built before the DC shows up rather than as a promise after.

jabroni_salad 25 minutes ago [-]
The text of the article indicates that the county government sent this message to all government facilities, but I suppose that doesn't make for quite as sexy a headline and a public school is technically a government facility.

I appreciate 404 media's mission but isn't there enough stupid shit existing naturally in the world for them to illuminate that we don't need to do this?

philipwhiuk 18 minutes ago [-]
> I appreciate 404 media's mission but isn't there enough stupid shit existing naturally in the world

Like 37 data centres in a small rural county?

1 minutes ago [-]
khuey 5 minutes ago [-]
This is suburban Richmond, not a "small rural county".
rdtsc 55 minutes ago [-]
The ~spice~ inference must flow.

Some of the data centers now run disconnected on gas turbines 24/7, which is better for electricity prices but they can be big nuisance for people living nearby.

culi 38 minutes ago [-]
It is also often a violation of the Clean Air Act but we don't have good regulation in place to actually hold them accountable
rho138 50 minutes ago [-]
downrightmike 24 minutes ago [-]
excess pollution and noise are more than a nuisance
preinheimer 58 minutes ago [-]
You want to use a lot of electricity? Great! We sell electricity. We will need cash in advance to handle some upgrades, rather than passing those costs on to other rate payers.
jimmydddd 11 minutes ago [-]
Exactly! Everyone's been conditioned that Data Centers = higher electric bills for residents. Of course, another option is for politicians to put any added costs on the data center companies. One tech guy even proposed, in order to gain wider acceptance, having the data center companies pay the whole electric bill for the town, so that data centers = 0 electric bills for residents.
arjie 55 minutes ago [-]
Interestingly, San Francisco has built no more of these AI datacenters and has seen a rate hike larger than that over the last few years. If we could at least get a few more datacenters that would be nice considering the rate hikes approved here.
Quinner 45 minutes ago [-]
That's because San Francisco subsidizes the rest of the state, PG&E is a state-wide utility. San Francisco is attempting to run its own utility, but is meeting resistance from PG&E and the parts of the state SF subsidizes.
downrightmike 22 minutes ago [-]
public infrastructure should be owned by the public
cmiles8 52 minutes ago [-]
Well I think the problem there is called “welcome to California.”
culi 39 minutes ago [-]
First of all, the grid is interconnected. Some random city building an AI datacenter could absolutely trigger price increases in a different part of the state. Second of all, Novva Data Centers is in fact building a $500m campus. In addition to all that is that the war against Iran is causing electricity prices to spike basically everywhere. PG&E is also currently modernizing its grid and doing wildfire hardening across the state. The solar subsidies has also meant that grid subsidization costs have been shifted onto non-solar customers.
malshe 41 minutes ago [-]
I love California and occasionally think about moving there. But the cost of living considerations bring me back to reality. Despite all its problems, it's difficult to leave Texas due to the low cost of living (and HEB!)
butterfi 39 minutes ago [-]
I might argue that we already have data centers, we just call then Colo Facilities.
dylan604 36 minutes ago [-]
I'd imagine your normal Colo facility uses a lot less power than an AI data center.
malshe 39 minutes ago [-]
Maybe the county could just ask its employees to work from home so that its office electricity bill goes down to zero. A win-win solution!
jeffbee 60 minutes ago [-]
Virginia (Dominion) electric rates went up dramatically, and are now in the same rough price band as 29 other states, because they were well below average. Important context, in my humble opinion.
gedy 45 minutes ago [-]
We can't leave money on the table for all those below average prices - so let's raise them all to the average... oh wait
cdrnsf 1 hours ago [-]
Unplug the data centers instead.
cmiles8 55 minutes ago [-]
Do we scale back AI slop for a few days or pull power back from schools? Easy, kids can suffer, give them some ice water.

The AI bubble can’t pop soon enough.

gadflyinyoureye 41 minutes ago [-]
Maybe it would help remove useless and harmful tech from schools. Books don't need batteries.
markvdb 1 hours ago [-]
Conserving energy makes sense regardless of nearby data center electricity consumption.
ben_w 18 minutes ago [-]
In much the same way that letting a fart out makes sense even when you're in a hurricane.

The list they give is overwhelmingly dominated by one item:

  “Turn off your lights when leaving your workspace, including when you leave for the day. Turn off your computers/laptops at the end of each workday.  If your workspace has windows, adjust the blinds to manage heat from sunlight.  Unplug any appliances, chargers, or other electrical items when they are not in use. Please limit use of (or refrain altogether from using) space heaters. A typical space heater alone can cost the county from $150 to $300 per year in electricity costs.”
Lights, these days, are going to be in the order of 10 W. A space heater, 1000-3000.

$20 of AI tokens over a month? Probably somewhere between, on average, 40-320 W, depending on how you weight the cost of training and which recent-ish model you're using.

Tokenmaxxers? They're the heavy users. $2k/month (or whatever) gets you a lot of electricity through those GPUs.

JohnFen 39 minutes ago [-]
True. But asking schools to conserve electricity while encouraging data centers to waste it is perverse.
jeffbee 59 minutes ago [-]
Yes, absolutely. This memo implies that with the same measures they could have saved 80% of the amount, regardless of the rate change. If that is significant they should have done this long ago.
Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact
Rendered at 17:16:35 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.